YouTube Is Pausing Premium Family Plans if You Aren't Watching From the Same Address

If you're sharing an ad-free YouTube Premium or YouTube Music account with friends or family who live outside of your home, you could lose your premium privileges. Customers who lose these can still stream on YouTube or listen to music with ads -- but let's be real, it's not the same.

Multiple reports have shown that people who have the service have been receiving notices that their premium service will be paused for 15 days due to violating a policy that's been in place since 2023.

Don't miss any of our unbiased tech content and lab-based reviews. Add CNET as a preferred Google source on Chrome.

A YouTube spokesperson told CNET, "Our family plan policy hasn't changed and we are continuously enforcing it. You can learn more about the YouTube family plan here."

On its support page, YouTube says that an account manager can add up to five family members in a household to their Premium membership. But, the post says, "Family members sharing a YouTube family plan must live in the same household as the family manager." Groups can only be changed once every 12 months.

YouTube has been testing a two-household plan that would offer a discount for those who want to share, but that plan is not yet available in the US.

YouTube offers a one-month trial for its Premium and Music accounts, which cost $23 per month.

YouTube joins other paid services that have started to enforce policies to cut down on the sharing of premium services.

Netflix and Disney Plus were among the services that began discouraging, and then actively blocking or restricting accounts they find are sharing passwords. Max joined them earlier this year, introducing an $8 fee for those who want to share their account with one other person.

Similarly, Amazon is ending a program that allowed for sharing of its Prime service, requiring that those who don't live at the same residence use their own paid Prime accounts for things like getting packages shipped for free. Amazon's Prime Invitee benefit-sharing program is ending on Oct. 1.

The enforcement is meant to help recover revenue that these companies say they lose when people use someone else's premium account instead of paying for their own.

"It's not hard to understand why streaming services feel the need to crack down. After all, the revenue to spend on new content or an improved experience must come from somewhere," says Carl Lepper, Senior Director of Technology, Media & Telecom (TMT) Intelligence at JD Power.

"The calculation from streaming companies seems to be that limiting password sharing and account access will lead to more subscribers. You could argue the same about any sort of subscription service. It's fairly intuitive. There's a solid amount of evidence from media coverage that it works, at least initially," Lepper says.

Does it work long-term? Lepper tells CNET that companies have to balance enforcing their policies without "ticking off" existing customers or denying potential customers from getting a chance to see what their service has to offer and potentially converting to their own account eventually.

Enforcement itself isn't free, he points out. "Streamers themselves need to devote time and resources to enforcing such a policy," Lepper says.